The Writing Process: Murdering Your Darlings

Diviner’s Nemesis II – Retribution - Maggie Shaw - Eregendal

How often have we as writers been told to murder our darlings? I first came across this advice while I was still in my teens. It was in a book written by my friend’s father, Victor Jones: Creative Writing, one of the Teach Yourself series. My signed copy of his book still sits on my bookshelf with the rhyming dictionary and the grammar books.

When I came to prepare Diviner’s Nemesis II – Retribution for publishing, I found a lot of darlings needed to be murdered. After some time away from the hand-written main draft, I looked at the novel with fresh eyes. The story came across as wandering and overblown, with a main character who lapsed into virtuous speeches at the drop of a hat, and a deus ex machina plot twist I had loved describing in the first draft, but which I now knew just wouldn’t do. A lot of scenes were little more than mundane padding, serving only to slow down the plot. And a large cast needed trimming down to help the reader keep track of who, what and where.

My first action was to prepare a chapter by chapter synopsis, noting the key plot points and the characters involved in each. This helped me identify all the unnecessary scenes and the characters I could drop completely, and also those where the detail could safely be included in another scene or passed to another character. For instance, I dropped a scene in a railway carriage completely, wrote out a second brother and a second bodyguard, and reduced three argument scenes to one key last argument where the main character says ‘Must we go through all this again,’ to hint at the two scenes that had gone before.

Removing the deus ex machina plot twist proved a lot more work as it involved restructuring the crux of that plot pivot. I still included the same scene – the attempted human sacrifice in the villain’s mansion – but in the revised version, the incident which stopped that sacrifice was the arrival of a priest sent by the main character’s estranged husband. That involved introducing several scenes to set up the rescue attempt – a friend’s concern alerting the husband and the priest to the main character’s kidnap, the priest organising the rescue party, and the opposition faced as they attempted the rescue.

The dropped chapters and written-out scenes had not been a waste of past writing time, for they still contributed to my understanding of the novel’s backstory, giving it much more depth. But the overall effect of murdering such darlings was to tighten up the sinister tale and make it much more of a page-turner.

Happy editing.
Maggie x.

Shopping Basket
Scroll to Top